STUDIO FIELDNOTES / MODERN & CONTEMPORARY BLACK ARTISTS / 9–12

Portraits with Agency

Zanele Muholi

Who controls the meaning of a portrait?

9–12photographic lighting, self-representation, caption4 printable resources
Get free lesson packet ↓
Original editorial cover graphic for Portraits with Agency
Original lesson-identification graphic. Open the credited research sources below to study actual artworks.

The investigation

Consent-based self-portrait and authored caption

Artist investigated: Zanele Muholi

What students discover

Affirm privacy, identity, and self-selection; no compulsory disclosure

The artmaking challenge

Develop an original artwork using photographic lighting, self-representation, caption. The final result is consent-based self-portrait and authored caption.

How it connects to learning

NCAS Visual Arts Creating, Responding and Connecting (anchor-level alignment); match grade-specific performance standards before instruction.

Responsible research

Explore an authorized museum image or artist portfolio. The image above is an original editorial cover graphic, not the artist’s artwork or likeness. Do not reproduce a contemporary work without permission.

Research starting points

Teach the artistic process

Ten deliberate studio moves.

A flexible sequence of investigation, experimentation, critique, and revision.

  1. 01 / Engage

    Show the inquiry question: Who controls the meaning of a portrait? Invite a noticing, a wonder, and an initial interpretation.

  2. 02 / Investigate

    Study at least two credited examples associated with Zanele Muholi. Affirm privacy, identity, and self-selection; no compulsory disclosure Students annotate the evidence that supports their thinking.

  3. 03 / Skill Studio

    Demonstrate photographic lighting, self-representation with a short material experiment. Students test the technique and record what changes.

  4. 04 / Generate

    Produce at least two distinct visual approaches to the challenge. Compare how each communicates the idea.

  5. 05 / Plan

    Choose an approach, identify materials and sketch a sequence of actions. Name one foreseeable difficulty.

  6. 06 / Produce

    Create the original artwork or design: Consent-based self-portrait and authored caption. Photograph or annotate work in progress.

  7. 07 / Critique

    Use evidence-based peer feedback: one element that communicates, one question, one suggested next move.

  8. 08 / Revise

    Make one visible revision in response to critique or new evidence. Record before-and-after choices.

  9. 09 / Present

    Display or share the result with a student-authored explanation and credits for research sources.

  10. 10 / Reflect

    Return to the inquiry question and explain what the work now communicates, what changed and what could improve next time.

Evidence of learning

Look for thinking, not sameness.

Use the shared Studio Fieldnotes criteria: inquiry and evidence, artistic decisions, process and revision, communication and connection.

  • Before Ask students to answer: Who controls the meaning of a portrait? Record a drawing, annotation or discussion response.
  • During Look for purposeful use of photographic lighting and a clear link between research evidence and design choices. Ask students to explain an alternative.
  • After Compare first plan and revised result; collect a student statement naming one choice, one change, and the evidence that motivated it.

Where might this investigation lead next?

Connect this lesson to a broader sequence, compare approaches across artists, or use the K–12 formative assessment system to document progress.